The Host's Guide to Shopping for a Memorable Holiday Dinner

The Host’s Guide to Shopping for a Memorable Holiday Dinner

Key Takeaways:

  • Knowing exactly who’s coming, kids and picky eaters included, tells you how much of everything to buy.
  • Most hosts need about 1 to 1 1⁄2 pounds per person for a whole bird or bone-in roast, and closer to ¾ pound for boneless cuts.
  • Shopping in stages over two to three weeks means you won’t be fighting the crowds for the last bag of fresh herbs.
  • A local butcher can cut, trim and hold your main dish for you before the holiday rush hits.

Most hosts can name the year something went wrong. Like the time the turkey was still frozen at noon, when the store ran out of fresh herbs or a time when there wasn’t enough food once the second helpings started. And a lot of the time, the plan starts to unravel at the store.

Hosts need to get the shopping part right when curating what they hope will be a memorable holiday dinner. So, know how much to buy, when to shop and where to source ingredients for the main dish.

Where Should Holiday Dinner Shopping Start?

Holiday dinner shopping should start with the guest list, since the number of people at the table decides how much of everything goes in the cart. Colorado State University Extension tells hosts to “know how many adults, teenagers, and younger children you will be serving.” A hungry teenager and a six-year-old don’t eat the same amount, after all.

Does anyone have allergies or food preferences you should know about? A vegetarian guest changes the side dishes, and that’s easier to plan two weeks out than the night before.

And if a friend’s new partner or a neighbor you’ve only met twice is coming, a small gift at their place setting goes a long way. This guide on how to choose a gift for someone you don’t know well has a few easy ideas.

Where Should Holiday Dinner Shopping Start

How Much Meat Will Be Enough for Your Guests?

Usually, one pound of meat is enough for one person. If you want leftovers or you’re feeding big eaters, go up to a pound and a half.

The type of cut matters, though, since bones and skin account for part of the weight:

Main DishAmount per Guest
Whole turkey or chicken1 to 1½ lbs
Bone-in roast or ham1 to 1½ lbs
Boneless roast or turkey breastAbout ¾ lb

When in doubt, round up. Just ask Ross Geller, who lost it at work when someone ate his leftover Thanksgiving sandwich, moist maker and all.

How Much Meat Will Be Enough for Your Guests

When Should Each Item Go on the Shopping List?

When you split the shopping across a few weeks, the last couple of days before the dinner get a lot less stressful. Writing the list out by store section, so produce, dairy, bakery, pantry, and then the meat counter, also helps because you won’t have to keep walking back through crowded aisles for things you missed.

Two to Three Weeks Out

Stock up on flour, broth, spices, canned goods, drinks, foil, and kitchen twine. This is also the time to place a special order for the main dish.

One Week Out

 Pick up frozen meat and plan the thaw. In the fridge, a frozen roast or turkey needs about one day for every four to five pounds, so a 20-pound bird takes around four days.

Two Days Out

Buy fresh meat, since raw meat only keeps in the fridge for one to two days. If the store is a long drive from home, carry a cooler bag to keep the meat at 40°F or below on the way back.

The Day Before

Grab bread, fresh herbs, salad greens, and anything else that wilts fast.

Why Does the Butcher Counter Deserve a Spot on the List?

With a local butcher, you get more control over the main dish than a pre-wrapped supermarket package gives you. They’ll cut a roast to the weight you need, trim and tie it, and hold it for pickup.

And if you’re not sure what to get, ask. A butcher will know which cut feeds ten people and how long it should roast.

The main dish is also where it makes sense to spend more. Cheaper broth or sugar won’t ruin the meal, but a bad centerpiece will, so it’s worth the extra stop.

Why Does the Butcher Counter Deserve a Spot on the List

Which Small Details Make the Dinner Feel Special?

Going for the title of ‘The host with the most’? Throw in cloth napkins, flowers, handwritten place cards, without forgetting a decent playlist. Maybe a few unscented candles too: smells are an important part of memory, and you want people remembering the food’s aroma, not the candle smell. They don’t cost much, but they’ll make your dinner ‘the benchmark’ every time the story gets retold. 

Ready to Shop for Your Holiday Dinner?

If you want a memorable holiday dinner, you need to know who’s coming, buy enough food for them, and spread the shopping out so the last day isn’t a rush. Once that’s sorted, the host gets to sit down and enjoy the evening with everyone else.

For a smaller group, you have a bit more room to splurge on the main dish. Rather than a big roast, a couple of thick cuts like an american wagyu steak, seared and sliced just before serving, make a great centerpiece for four people, and it doesn’t need hours in the oven.